Do Suicides Go To Hell?
Friday, September 3rd, 2010
If you have clicked on this article – l expect that you may possibly have lost someone to this unfortunate end or are merely searching for the answer to this question. As you can see l have somewhat of a personal interest in this area having lost my only daughter to suicide. It is also a place that l am all too familiar with, having been snatched back from the brink of suicide myself; however the reality of the emotions and the desperation that engulfed me at that time are still a vivid memory for me today.
Through my experience with Jade l have seen that there is clearly an inability for people to minister into this situation. What to say to someone who has lost a loved one is hard enough, but when the situation is complicated by suicide it becomes even more complex and when you add a murder, now people are really going to struggle with how to minister into a crisis like this. To be honest more people will want to avoid contact so as to avoid the awkwardness or when they see you blurt out a comment like ‘you okay’ as they walk past you at a brisk pace hoping that you won’t burst into tears and then they will have to deal with what to do next, relieved that you have said ‘yes’ now they’re off the hook. Some will just brush it under the carpet in a hope that ‘out of sight is out of mind’ a little naive unfortunately. And then to the other extreme it was said to me recently that ‘suicides go to hell’, now on a scale of 1-10 that ranked 0 as definitely not helpful. Another response was as l hadn’t seen my daughter for several years that it would be easier for me to deal with, well I’m not sure in what world that comment works but it doesn’t work in mine. So l am left wondering how many other people who have lost a loved one the same way have also encountered the above. No judgment is made on any of the above responses but….
This is the gap l see and the gap l want to fill. However, in order to do so some scriptural understanding needs to be shed on this issue, along with a response to some of the arguments to what the final eternal destination is for someone who has taken their own life. Our ability to gain clarity from God’s perspective will enable us to minister effectively when the need arises, and it will. This is a journey that will be undertaken with humility as there will be questions raised to which there are no conclusive answers.
As you can imagine there are so many aspects to this question that l want to address, some of them are as follows:
- What does the Bible say about suicide?
- What is the Biblical understanding about our position in judging the eternal destinations of people?
- What influence if any is there of the demonic in such circumstances?
- What factor does depression play?
- What is the heart of God?
- How can l effectively minister into such a crisis?
Writing this article will be a progressive journey, due to its complexity and scope …. so follow along as l add to this each week. If this section which will also have a strong apologetic focus (give reason for why we believe), interests you, you may wish to subscribe so that when it is updated you will be notified automatically.
Wednesday, September 8th 2010
What does the Bible say about suicide?
Surprisingly there are seven suicides that involve humans mentioned in the Bible along with a herd of swine, plus one attempted suicide.
Abimelech (Judges 9:54) – He ordered his armor bearer to slay him when a woman dropped a millstone on his head from on top of a tower, because he didn’t want it known that a woman killed him…somewhat undignified one would expect!
Samson (Judges 16:26-31) – The Philistines had captured Samson and taken out his eyes, and put him in chains in prison. When they paraded him before the people in order to make sport of him, he asked a lad to help place his hands on the pillars of the temple between which he was placed and then he prayed to God that his strength return one last time so that with one blow he could dislodge the pillars, topple the temple and kill all the Philistines gathered therein. He would also have die in the process, a fact of which he was well aware. Samson was at one time a Godly man but he allowed pride & disobedience into his life and as a result was taken captive by God’s enemies.
Saul (1Samuel 31:3-6) - Saul fell on his own sword because he was fearful that the Philistines would subject him to torture, but only after his armor bearer refused to take his life. Saul was at one time a Godly man but he allowed pride to enter his life and then he turned his back on the Lord.
Ahithophel (2Samuel 17:1,23) - Put his house in order and then hanged himself after his plot to overthrow David failed. Ahithophel’s counsel was highly regarded, almost as though it were an oracle of God (2 Sm 16:23). He was King David’s trusted counselor who turned traitor and joined Absalom’s conspiracy.
Zimri (1 Kings 16:18) – Usurped the throne of Israel and was King for 7 days; when his city was taken, he burned down the palace around himself. A man known for his duplicity and cruelty.
Judas Iscariot (Matthew 27:4-5) – Realizing the enormity of what he had done in betraying Jesus went out and hung himself.
Herd of swine (Mark 5:1-14) – After having been sent out by Jesus from a demonized man they entered into a herd of swine and sent 2000 of them off the precipice.
The jailer at Philippi (Acts 16:26-29) – Attempted suicide under the mistaken belief that his prisoners had escaped during an earthquake; loosing a prisoner was punishable by death, however Paul stopped him. Later he and his whole household came to faith in Jesus Christ.
What does the Bible say about their eternal destinations?
In one word – ‘nothing’ - the Bible merely records these events and makes no judgment on their eternal states. The type of people the Bible records as having taken their lives vary; from people who once had a relationship with God, but turned their back on Him, people who never had a relationship with God, and even one who turned his hand against the Messiah. And yet the Bible is silent on their eternal destinations.
However the Bible is concerned about our eternal destinations and where we spend eternity is based on the following : Romans 10:9 “If you confess the Lord Jesus, and believe in your heart that God raised Him from the dead, you shall be saved” Romans 10:13 ” Whoever shall call upon the name of the Lord will be saved.”
What is the Biblical understanding about our position in judging the eternal destinations of people?
Simply stated – ‘we are given no authority to judge.’ The Bible from Genesis to Revelation (too many scriptures to list), clearly and without any variation states that the judging of people’s eternal destination is the role of the Father & the Son. Why? Because we are unable to see the heart of man, this is only something that God can do. Psalms 44:21 says “…For He knows the secrets of the heart.” Jeremiah 17:10 states, “I, the Lord, search the heart, I test the mind, even to give every man according to his ways, according to the fruit of his doings.”
Thursday, September 30th 2010
What influence if any is there of the demonic in such circumstances?
Without doubt this will prove to be insightful. There are varying opinions on this subject. We are not talking about images of Casper the friendly ghost, we are talking about the reality of a demonic realm that has as its agenda to destroy all that God holds precious namely, humanity.
When l first became a born again believer, l had the rare experience of seeing into the spirit realm. lt was as though a veil had been lifted between the tangible world and the invisible realm the spirit world, for a brief few seconds. l saw standing in the front yard of the home that my children occupied with their father at the very least a dozen giant over 6ft tall dark figures in the shape of humans standing watching and waiting. Immediately l prayed for their protection.
Jade for many years unbeknown to myself had episodes where she would become delirious and see demonic creatures coming at her, terrifying creatures, she would be feverish and would take a day or two to recover. Her father who was a doctor would nurse her through these events and they were taken as epileptic fits. Unfortunately she only told me of those events when she was 15. We discussed them and l was shocked that she never mentioned them before to anyone, it was something she just carried inside her. It is hard to gauge what effect on the mind such experiences had on her, she was so brave and never made a fuss about anything, never complained, never displayed any dysfunctional behavior that would lead one to suspect there were deeper issues smoldering beneath the surface.
In this day and age we are all too aware of the presence of the demonic, we see it on the big screen, we attribute the depravity of humanity to its influence, so this reality is not foreign to us at all. Biblically the demonic realm is exposed for the murderous agender that it has. In the Old Testament we see people were mutilating themselves in an attempt to appease their gods, these were the gods of the pagan nations that surrounded the Israelite nation. It was never something that the God of the Hebrews required.
All that stands in opposition to God is inspired by the demonic.
Take the time to read these accounts – 1Kings 18 - Elijah was on Mt Carmel in a showdown with the pagan Canaanite god Baal and Yahweh, the God of Israel. In order to provoke their god to action the people started to self harm themselves ‘as was the custom with knives and lances until blood gushed out of them.’
Jeremiah 32:35 ‘And they built the high places to Baal, in the valley of the son of Hinnom, to cause their sons and daughters to pass through the fire, that which l did not command them, nor did it come up into My mind that they should do this abomination...’ (2Kings 23:10; Leviticus 18 & 20).
These are just a few mentioned here, if we fast forward to the New Testament we see the account of the demoniac of the Gadarenes in Mark 5, Matthew 8 & Luke 8 these are parallel accounts with some differences in their details. Here the man is self harming himself , exhibits extraordinary strength, violent, naked and out of his mind. The response of the demon at the sight of Jesus was to reveal that he was not one demon inhabiting this man but in fact his name was Legion meaning that there were many inhabiting and controlling this man. A Roman legion is about 6,000, so clearly space constraints are not an issue when it comes to possession, many can inhabit or possess 1 person.
to be continued…..






jc
April 3, 2011 at 7:58 AM
What does the Bible say about suicide? Well its not ok or we would all be able to do it without any thought of the matter. If one is not suppose to defile the temple of God. which our bodies are Gods holly temple we are to take care of, if we defile that temple have we sinned? You better believe it. When we die it’s too late to ask for forgivness. We can twist gods words any way we want but when the Lord gives us a set of instructions those do not change God does not change. Every word God either had written or told someone to write is as it is. God is the same today as He was yesterday and today and forever. that is serious stuff. So is it wrong yes. Where will you go? that’s Gods judgement. But I wouldn’t chance it by disobeying him.
jc
April 3, 2011 at 8:26 AM
One more thing about suicide. are you trying to defend it? Demons entered the swine not people. I know without a doubt there is no in – between ify contemplations over this matter. You have to take out the pretexts to your contexts of the scriptures. This subject is not debateable and its not a touchy or hard subject to talk about. It is clear which God made clear – If we disobey God without repenting then we are going to Hell and it is real about 45 times Hell is decribed in the Bible. So all our theology in the world wont save us. Getting our hearts right with God in love with Him in the only thing that will save us. The knowing in our hearts that Jesus died for our sins. His blood saved us. One little sin is like a great big sin they are the same. So if one wants to defile the temple of God your body I guess you have that right but it’s not just about self- murder. You deliberatley disobey our Father in heaven. We cant say “dear Lord forgive me for what I am about to do.” God does not work that way. Better yet ” forgive me Lord for killing this person tomorrow.” The bottom line is to obey God – die to the old self and put away our old sinful ways and desires and love him. Trust and obey.
astridstaley
April 3, 2011 at 8:16 PM
Thank you JC for you black and white comments. Yes demons entered the swine but before they did they were in a person and totally possessed that person to an extent that the person was not in their right mind nor able to control their actions. Jesus came and initiated deliverance without that persons request because he knew that that person was unable to initiate that request.
No-one is justifying suicide – but one thing we do note in scripture is that God NEVER makes a verdict on suicide – as you rightly stated he merely records those words- we in our hardness make these judgements – (a bit of research will take you back to Augustine ‘City of God’ where this black and white statement was 1st articulated and why- mainly because of facination with voluntary martydom for Christ as a way out of this life).
The second thing that we note in scripture is that – self-harm is not congruent with the heart of God – that being so where do these thoughts of suicide come from? They can only have one origin Devil – OT as they cut their wrists to invoke Baal – sacrificed their children to Baal – demoniac experiences in the NT where the demons take control of the person and throw them into the fire and try to kill them – keep them sick – etc…. NT the grace of God is such that where a person is unable to help themselves the grace of God reaches them where they are at – and makes them whole.
There is allot that we do not know about the final moments of death – people have died and come back tell us of vivid encounters with God and insight even visits into hell and heaven – may we never be so graceless and judge what their eternal state is of someone that has that has passed already – We have not been called to do that.
The word of God states “those who confess Jesus as Lord, and believe that He was raised from the dead is saved” Rom. 10:9, 13
Can you say JC that in the final moments that a person has not said that? Can you say JC that a God of infinite grace cannot reach into a person’s insane moment and rescue them when they have no ability to rescue themselves? JC can you limit the grace of God to a person who was not in their right mind one who gave their heart to the Lord at as a teenager, this then impacts you view of whether one can lose one’s salvation or not? JC do you know the heart and intentions of peoples thoughts? JC do you know the end from the beginning? (Book of Job)
If a person was to present themselves to me tomorrow with suicidal tendencies l would not scare them with Hell – l would try to get to the bottom of these thoughts and get them some counseling help but minister them the grace of God and make them aware that self-harm is not from God inviting them home, or offering them relief from their trouble but identify the demonic influence that is tormenting them, and find out the emotional roots that are associated with this. l would 100% speak against this as being okay in any way shape or form!
Whilst they are alive l can minister that hope to them – but few people afford us that luxury who intend to kill themselves – those that intend and tell are those who are asking and begging if you like for help – there we have hope – but those who do without warning -are too far gone and the voice that beckons them is totally and wholly evil, – and of them we say “God is a God of infinite, immeasurable grace and knows our hearts and minds and is the only one who has the authority to judge any persons eternal state”
Blessings Ps. Astrid Staley
Christian Ayling
August 10, 2011 at 3:57 AM
I think this is an interesting read. The reason I am studying at Harvest is to work toward being a Grace preacher. Now, that may seem a strange thing to say to some, as one might think that narrows the preaching of the word. However, the entire bible is divided in Jesus conceiled (OT) and Jesus revealed (NT) and the NT divided into before and after the cross. Jesus IS the Grace of God. The law was given as a mirror to show man’s sin, so that they would realise that through their own pride in trying to follow the law and failing, that they would discover they needed a saviour. The fact is, the bible very clearly shows us the heart of our Abba Father and He knows the heart of His children. We are nothing, in and of ourself. If one action was to separate us from God for eternity, Heaven would be a lonely place because no one would make it. Who is to judge what sin is greater than the other? His Grace is sufficient. Jesus died for all our sins, past, present and future. When you recieve Him, you receive this gift… and it is a gift that is indesereved. So, then when you receive this gift and then go on to believe that your acts can undo your salvation, you are being self righteous. Because you are saying that your works are the reason for your salvation or maintaining it. God has shown us time and time again, that it has little to do with us and more to do with him. I think it is fair to say that a judgmental belief about God’s judgement of what happens when someone suicides would indicate that person is still trying to follow the law. In fact, we cannot follow the law efficiently or balance law and Grace because Grace fulfilled the law. If you receive salvation, how can you balance what has been fulfilled. The Holy Spirit replaced the need to follow the law, and is our guide to righteous living. But even then, we fail daily. God’s Grace existed before the law was introduced. Remember Kane killed Abel? Did God strike Kane down? No, he placed a mark of proctection over him so that no one would harm him. There are countless examples of this through the bible.
I love Roman’s……Roman’s 5:20 – ‘The law was added so that the trespass might increase. But where sin increased, grace increased all the more, 21so that, just as sin reigned in death, so also grace might reign through righteousness to bring eternal life through Jesus Christ our Lord.’
I have a personal interest in the subject of suicide and I commend you on being brave to write this.
All I can say is that I am glad I know I can rest in my Abba Father who’s Grace is sufficient enough for me.
Christian Ayling
astridstaley
August 10, 2011 at 5:03 AM
Hi Christian,
l like the track your on as far as Grace preaching is concerned. But grace is much bigger than the Salvation picture which had been my understanding prior to my experience.. think about the Apostle Paul…not alway related to salvation but for power to go through. The magnitude of Grace is quite vast …enjoy the journey… Blessings Ps. Astrid
l will put the link to the publication up shortly.
Christian Ayling
August 10, 2011 at 6:11 AM
Amen! That’s for sure.Thankyou for your encouragement